They actually did it. Well, sort of. Facing mobs in the streets (as well they should); the Cyprus government, the European Union (EU), and the International Monetary Fund (IMF), looted billions (of euros) from the state owned Cyprus banks this weekend (3/25/2013)
So what exactly happened? I like bullet points (Type A Analytical), so let’s go with that.
- Cyprus is a European Socialist Democracy run by leftist. Thus spending has never really matched income.
- This system eventually collapsed; just like every system that mirrors it will (are you getting this EU and US?)
- Cyprus is just ahead of the rest of the EU so they are seeking a “bailout” from their “not there yet” cousins; namely Germany. Italy and Spain can’t really help because they are just a few steps behind Cyprus.
- The EU (mostly Germany) and the IMF have demanded that Cyprus pony up some money in exchange for the €10 billion in bailout funds. Recently they got specific and demanded that Cyprus raise this money (about €5 billion) by raiding Cyprus banks.
- Conveniently or by design all this crap just happened to come down during a week-long “bank holiday”; making it impossible for people to withdraw lots of money. The Cyprus government used this as an opportunity (“never let a serious crisis go to waste” after all) to limit daily withdrawals to 100 euros. The peasants could still go crazy after all and need to be protected from themselves. Oh, and the government made it impossible to transfer accounts anywhere; basically telling foreign depositors “WE have your money and WE will decide how much of it you get back.”
- The Cyprus Government floated the idea of “taxing” ALL accounts about 6-10%; which is what it would take to raise the demanded €5 billion.
- This idea didn’t go well with the Cyprus citizens (also known as peasants). So the Cyprus Government instead decided to NOT tax the peasants (they are local and have pitchforks); but instead tax just “the rich”; who have fewer pitchforks and many of whom are not local. (Victims with pitchforks thousands of miles away are a good thing in the eyes of those who are doing the robbing.) But because the looters aren’t spreading the pain; the percentage “tax” on each account affected will be more in the 40% range (the government estimates 30% so I assume 40-50) for confiscation. “An EU spokesman said NO across-the-board levy or tax would be imposed on deposits in Cypriot banks, although the hit on large account holders in the two biggest banks is likely to be far greater than initially planned. A first attempt at a deal last week collapsed when the Cypriot parliament rejected a proposed levy on all deposits.” – Reuters
- This scheme made the EU and IMF happy (they got the concession), and the peasants happy (they kept their money and their bread and circuses). The only few people who are mad are a few rich people in Cyprus and a lot of rich Russians who are far, far away.
- Problem solved. Well, kind of… Cyprus is still a Socialist Democracy run by leftist… so it’s really just a band-aid. But why squabble over semantics?
Some Thoughts on the Whole Mess:
Placating the Masses
This really seems to have worked as far as placating the Cyprus peasants. “Many in the capital appeared intent on enjoying a sunny holiday morning, drinking coffee at pavement cafes and watching camera crews filming people drawing money from bank machines.” – Reuters
I’m also sure the bread and circuses have not abated in the least.
Inevitable
Make no mistake about it, the Cyprus banking system would have collapsed without a deal of a bailout from the EU or the IMF.
“It is a bad deal, but the extreme scenario we had to contend with was worse.” — Lefteris Christoforou, vice-chairman of the ruling Democratic Rally party
Guess what. It’s still inevitable. When you subsidize bad behavior (socialist deficit spending), even with stolen money you get more of that behavior.
Thieves Stealing from Thieves
“There is no honor among thieves.” Much (though not all) of the money looted was taken from Russian mafia oligarchs. As Charles Krauthammer said “It couldn’t have happened to a nicer bunch of people.” But we (Charles and I) know this was just coincidence. Had the money been the lifesaving of little old ladies from Peoria, it would have been just as gone, just a quickly.
Why Stop There
Cyprus was a “safe haven” for the foreign (Russian) money; kind of like the Cayman Islands are for American money. My question is why did the Greeks/Cyprus stop there? Why not take ALL of it or 90% or 80%? Why so little?
Do they think the Russians (and the rich) will just say “Man, what a rip.” And leave what remains of their deposits within the clutches of those who just robbed them? Of course not, they will transfer every cent as soon as they are able.
To get this deal, Cyprus has sacrificed its foreign banking industry. It will never recover. I’m just asking was €4 or €5 billion worth it when they just as easily could have taken €10 billion? It’s not as if those being “taxed” had ANY say in the matter or the amount.
The answer to my question “Why Stop There?” is, of course, they stopped at the point where they rationalized they could get away with it… without Russian missiles streaming in or Russian tanks rolling down the streets. Vladimir Putin does have his limits. Just ask his enemies… well those not poisoned or dead under mysterious circumstances. 🙂
Who’s Next
Spain and Italy are just a step or two behind Cyprus. Those guys are in terrible, terrible shape.
So I ask you… If you had any amount of money in Spainish or Italian banks; would you leave it there? I wouldn’t.
Sure, other European banks are fine (for now); and the same can be said for U.S. banks… so do we have nothing to worry about?
Conclusion
This is stuff that could have easily been in “Atlas Shrugged”; and it’s why that book is so relevant to today’s society. The looters as depicted in that book are alive, well, and active in Europe. They bide their time here (in the U.S.).
Many on the left will say that this could “never” happen here. By “never” they mean today… and they are wrong.
It is already happening here; jut much, much more subtlety. Every time Ben Bernanke prints another dollar (and he’s printing billions of them) he IS in effect devaluing the dollars we own to finance big leftist government. It is, in all practical purposes, the same thing. He’s just boiling the frog (us) slower.
But could we ever reach a point where our creditors demand that our government “tax” deposits, or savings accounts, or retirement accounts, etc… OR they will not lend us any more money? Could you see China doing that? I sure could.
But could you see the government (currently run by leftist with the same mentality as those in Europe) actually doing that… not all of us… just the rich? Yep! They would do it and the people would let them. Even today the propaganda has convinced us that those evil rich bastards deserve it.
No; it’s not going to happen literally tomorrow; but tomorrow as in within a decade? It could easily happen here; and it’s the direction we are headed at a dead run.
Read Full Post »