The issue of higher education has hit the news lately because of Rick Santorum calling Obama a snob concerning his comments that everyone should be able to go to/afford a college education. This is one of my pet peeves about American society today.
I think Santorum and I are on the same page though neither of us can articulate our positions very well. Should we strive as a society to get everyone though a basic level of education? Yes. Should we strive to make college (junior and university) affordable and be sure that everyone gets his/her chance at higher education? NO.
Yes, Obama is a snob when it comes to higher education; but so are most politicians (because of polls) and maybe even most Americans. The very definition of success in this country has become a college degree; and THAT is the problem. The idea is flat out wrong AND very Un-American. Can college be a path to success, yes… but it can also be a path to failure as many in the Occupy movement have discovered. Anyone who can do a little cost/reward analysis can deduce where the educated losers went wrong.
We have lost our industrial and manufacturing spirit in this nation. Why?
- Work Ethic – young people don’t have it anymore (largely because of entitlements, and unions) Just getting people to show up every day and on-time is a nightmare. It wouldn’t be if they knew their food and shelter were dependent on those traits.
- Drugs – People can’t pass a simple drug test; causing attendance, quality, safety, and litigations problems that make them unemployable. That’s OK though, we have a safety net. Again, it would be less of a problem if people knew their job, food and shelter were dependent on not taking drugs.
- Education – Yes, manufacturing jobs do take a different set of skills today than years past. So? Apprenticeships and trade schools are more than enough to handle those challenges; even though high schools should be meeting them. We just need people to realize and take advantage of that.
Everyone is about training, training, and training. Newt Gingrich thinks it should be a requirement for unemployment. Obama and others think we need to fill the junior colleges and universities to the brim. But if all we’re doing is producing educated idiots, what good have we done? We’ve done no favors to the “educated”, the employers, or society… In fact we’ve done all three great harm.
That’s where we’ve got to fundamentally change the American attitude about education… all education at all levels.
Start with; Public education is not a decade plus baby-sitting service. It’s not an entitlement. Nothing will get that point across like the parents suffering some of consequences of their kid’s bad behavior. And set standards. Once a kid reaches a certain age and still disrupts the teaching of his/her peers… cut your losses. Offer attitude adjustment and “training” in the rehabilitation centers.
We should transform our schools into institutions that help kids transition into working adults; with some attention to higher education (already in place), some attention to useful trades, and a lot more attention to common sense.
By useful trades, I’m talking about those skills needed in agricultural, retail, manufacturing, transportation, and even some business positions. They don’t require “higher education” but good training in the skills related to those fields would really give the kids a leg up. This area of education is completely ignored in our culture, and here’s proof…
“Factory jobs have become both high tech and high salaried. An aspiring machinist—a popular factory job—can start training at 18 and then do a one-or two-year manufacturing apprenticeship. In five years, he or she could be making more than $50,000. In 10 years, that could double to $100,000.” — CNN Money (Most college educated workers would (should) kill for that kind of salary and stability)
“5 percent of manufacturing jobs remained unfilled simply because they could not find workers with the right skills.” — Deloitte Consulting LLP survey (I shudder to think of how many jobs go unfilled because of substance abuse.)
“That 5 percent vacancy rate meant that an astounding 600,000 jobs were left unfilled during a period when national unemployment was above 9 percent.” — Wall Street Journal (Yet the safety net worked just fine during that period.)
By common sense I’m talking basic skills needed as an adult. How many kids coming out of High School can balance a check book or create a budget? How many really understand the dangers of running up credit card bills?
Now, I’m not saying that we direct students to this or that field based on what some school official thinks that kid can handle. I still have my healthy distrust of anybody working for government at whatever level. I also have a highly developed sense of individual freedom. These decisions squarely belong to the child with guidance from the parents. The only purpose of the school is advice and implementation.
Yes, we need an educated populace to compete in this new world economy. But just educated isn’t enough (as I hope we are discovering). We need people educated in useful fields. And need people educated in a cost effective manner… and higher education as it exists today is not designed to do that.
Read Full Post »